There’s a new dynamic duo in Gotham City. After taking out General Grimaldi, Clayface & Two-Face have taken over! They have “clay” sleeper agents planted throughout the city. By replacing Gotham’s power players with their own has given them leverage. No one is safe. Not even Bruce Wayne.
Dick Grayson was removed from his custody. Fake evidence has ruled him unfit as a parent. His Manor was taken siege. There’s nowhere safe to run.
That is just the odds Batman likes…
BATMAN AND ROBIN: YEAR ONE #11 by Mark Waid, Chris Samnee, Mat Lopes and Clayton Cowles brings forth its pen-ultimate issue.
Let’s not wait any longer to dive into the chapter!
BATMAN AND ROBIN: YEAR ONE #11 by Mark Waid, Chris Samnee, Mat Lopes and Clayton Cowles (DC Comics)
*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***
Waid crafts a very high-stakes affair right from the start. Seeing Batman forced undercover leads to questions of denial and doubt. The dialogue with Alfred shows how farthings have slipped out of grasp. It doesn’t defer the attempt to stop “Grimaldi”. The action picks up as Batman swings into action. It exposes a fatal flaw in Grimaldi’s plans. The revelations don’t stop here. Another one takes over the book and haunts to the close.
Readers watch as Batman questions his adopting of Dick Grayson. The Dark Knight watches Grayson have some normalcy. It leads to a self exploration of emotions. Grayson’s reaction is surprising in return. Readers don’t dwell on this aspect for long. Batman wastes no time in trying to take down everyone solo. This is met with mixed results. There is an air of carelessness looming with the attack. Once in the final stages, the errors prove costly. It shifts tones towards a dire direction. The last page shows a glimmer of hope as the truth sinks in: There’s a reason Batman needs a Robin.
Samnee and Lopes bring out the dark side of the new regime with the art. Opening with Batman undercover and running sets an early pace. The interactions with Alfred suggest how costly the failure is. Readers see how this carries over to Batman on the offensive. The panels showcase the sleuth moves as the picture comes into focus. It leaves a few noteworthy action images behind as the spotlight shifts.
The art shows the wide range of emotional pulls involved with Grayson’s separation. While brief, every panel is maximized for page time. It elevates the moment to become a motivator. Pacing ramps up as Batman progresses his mission forward. There is plenty of big action to go around here. It leads to more tense moments. The vintage Batman rage is clearly on display. It gives way to a monstrous closing act. This ultimately moves into a grave closing page. Save for the last panel, it shows the Bat in a new light. That panel shows a possible redemption from an unlikely source. The path to the close is perfectly set.
OVERALL GRADE: 9.4
Clayface & Two-Face advance their plans further while forcing Batman to question himself. Waid’s writing takes readers along for Bat’s doomed, valiant effort. Samnee and Lopes shine with fantastic action and deep emotions. The stage is now set for an unforgettable close to drop.
Let me know in the comments below your thoughts on Batman and Robin: Year One #11. Thanks for reading!