BOOK OF BUTCHER #1 by James Tynion IV Werther Dell’Edera (BOOM! Studios)

Welcome to an all-new edition of Parlay points, the comic book review blog to the ODPH Podcast!

For this entry, we are heading back to the world of one of Comics’ best series. Since its’ debut, the dangerous world of the Order of St. George has been a home to comic fans and critics. Something Is Killing The Children by BOOM! STUDIOS is consistently winning awards and is slated for a live-action show on Netflix.

As for comics, it has already spawned off another series, House Of Slaughter, with a special one-shot debuting last year: Book Of Slaughter. Now nearly a year later, the story of Maxine Slaughter continues.

BOOK OF BUTCHER #1 by James Tynion IV Werther Dell’Edera Miquel Muerto AndWorld Design, Tate Brombal, Antonio Fuso, Letizia Cadonici, and Chris Shehan picks right up where things left off. Let’s take a closer look and see how Maxine’s life has changed.

*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***

After dealing with the death of Aaron Slaughter, Maxine contemplates the future. Cecilia, the aplha of her Withe Mask pack, presents her with a unique offer. With a shortage of Black Masks (solo hunters), there is a need to have more for the Order. The process is difficult to change masks. Maxine finds this out when she digs into the history of Erica Slaughter and the Order itself. Even with this knowledge, Maxine agrees to change.

The story begins with in the swamps of New Orleans. Maxine returns to a house. She is wielding axes covered in blood. A man watches and asks her if something is dead. Maxine replies with pushback. Maxine claims she doesn’t even know what she is hunting. Their banter is aggressive. Readers soon find out that the man is Louis Boucher, Maxine’s trainer to becoming a Black Mask.

After a meeting with Cecilia about her current situation, the story shifts back to the house in the Swamp. Maxine walks into Louis’ office. Maxine is asking for food and help. The response she gets is less than warm. Louis hands her a book. Inside are the pages to further her journey along.

Readers tag along as Maxine dives into the history of monsters via the House of Boucher. The information is vital in Maxine’s growth in becoming an independent hunter. The information also creates a new dynamic between Louis and Maxine.

Making moves in the shadows is Cecelia. She passes along where Maxine’s next stop should lead her. Readers of SIKTC know this place all too well. However, before heading there, Maxine still has more to learn from Louis. The final act throws a swerve into the situation. An idea is mentioned that looks to play a greater impact on Maxine’s story that she could ever imagine. The final panel’s chilling words cement that before leaving readers until next time.

Tynion challenges Maxine’s concept of what hunting is all about. The dynamic between her and Louis is rocky at best. Louis comes across as gruff and unapologetic. The debate about her learning is a version of “tough love” which offsets Maxine. The writing shows Maxine struggling to absorb the knowledge Louis is passing along. This remedies out by the final act, where it appears Louis gives her a lesson in trust.

The writing also plays up Cecilia as a difficult teacher in her own right. Their conversations are more pleasant than the ones with Louis. They also reflect the dangerous tasks that lie ahead for Maxine. This comes full circle in the final act. As Louis as been tested, his words become haunting as the latest lesson has been taught with a hint of doubt thrown in the mix.

The art duties are split throughout the issue. Maxine and Louis’ story gives readers a tense, uneasy lesson in hunting monsters. Cecelia’s story comes to life with subtle reactions while Maxine tries stating her issues wit Louis. The Boucher book is filled with excellent images of the monsters that live in the Slaughter-verse. It’s a complete package of telling multiple tales while keeping things moving in the same direction.

The final act is filled with a darker coloring scheme that illustrates the horrors Maxine thinks she is facing. The imagery translate more than the reader thinks. Balanced by the writing, the closing panels plant the seeds for something more sinister on the way.

FINAL POINT: 8.5

Maxine Slaughter’s transformation in the Order of St. George enters a new level with a stand-out tale. With Tynion’s strong writing guiding the all-star line-up of creators into creating a story of knowledge and trust, this will be one for fans not to pass on for New Comic Book Day!

Hit me up on ODPH social media and let me know your thoughts on Book Of Butcher #1. Thanks for reading!