Welcome to an all-new edition of Parlay Points, the comic book review blog to the ODPH podcast.

For this entry, we’re following the fantastic murder-mystery unfolding in the world of Kiros via the pages of the smash hit new series from Image Comics! Black Cloak #4 by Kelly Thompson, Meredith McClaren and Becca Carey has been giving readers much excitement as they follow Black Cloaks Phaedra Essex and Pax trying to crack the case surrounding a death involving a member of Kiros’ royal family. With recent events, the case is heating up so why wait any longer! Let’s see what’s unfolding in the latest chapter, shall we?

Black Cloak #4
Creative: Kelly Thompson, Meredith McClaren and Becca Carey
Credit: Image Comics

*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***

Freyal III of Sidra is found dead in a seedy part of Kiros. The heir to the royal throne is one of three deaths that appear to be connected. Black Cloaks (Kiros Law Enforcement) Phaedra Essex and Pax have been assigned on the case, but their investigation has drawn a lot of unwanted attention, even resulting in attempts on Essex’s life (due to her past history with Freyal). Due to the fallout the death has caused, Kiros is on the edge of a meltdown. It has also led to a possible shift in power from Elves to Humans. Once the Kiros Three (the most influential humans on Kiros) pay Essex a visit, they send her in a direction of a new lead in solving the case.

The cloaks make their way from “The Trees”, (a section of Kiros) to a hidden location that Freyal and Essex knew about. It is at this moment that Essex is hit with the information that the murder might have actually been a suicide, covering something else. From this fallout, Essex and Pax head back to “The Lagoon”, where two other bodies were found to dive deeper into what really happened.

This chapter opens up with Essex and Pax underwater with the mermaids who reside there as well as Sash, who is trying to guide them thru this new area of Kiros. The cloaks start hearing and seeing things that are not there. Sash has to break them out of their trances, warning that the sounds and sights they see are not real. Sash pleads with Sabri to help Essex and Pax but she is none too pleased the pair is searching. With a sonic scream, the pair is broken from their trance. With a last ditch plea, Sabri reveals who dumped the body filled with poison into the Lagoon. Both Essex and Pax are not happy with that result.

Piecing together the information they recovered, Essex and Pax try coming up with a plan to expose the guilty party. However, fate doesn’t seem to be on their side as a move is made to silence their actions. While laying low, Essex dives into her past and reveals some secrets that have been looming around her since the beginning. Readers’ patience in waiting will be rewarded with an eye-opening disclosure to one of the biggest plot threads of the series thus far! From this stage, drastic times call for drastic actions as Essex and Pax’s investigation leads them down a path that won’t be expected to conclude this excellent issue on.

BREAKDOWN: Thompson delivers an impactful reveal to the readers that was well worth the wait. Essex’s connection to the case has been the biggest driving factor behind her motivations. Getting clarification about that moment of time gives a whole new perspective about what is unfolding now. Readers can easily connect with that moment and empathize with what is transpiring. The before and after this sequence stands out as well. Seeing the cloaks in a new environment that they’re not comfortable with made for a solid break from the “normal” placement we’ve seen previously. With their latest situation sending Essex and Pax into a new setting, Thompson never lets up on keeping the story fresh and unpredictable. There are so many moving parts to the overall picture but nothing feels forgotten or missed. Going into the conclusion, all the major points are hit to drop a moving final point to end things on here.

McClearn brings the underwater world of The Lagoon to an incredible visual experience. The coloring used in this portion of the story pops off the page, especially diving into when the mermaids were influencing the cloaks. The imagery gives that moment a distinct feel that doesn’t appear on previous trips through Kiros. The flashback sequence reveal connects and gives readers a well-placed section of story that will only amplify where things head involving Essex. In a short-term payoff, the mannerisms Essex displays in the final act become that more impactful heading into the final page. This book doesn’t miss on giving readers an exceptional trip through such a mysterious and amazing world.

FINAL POINT: Black Cloak #4 keeps their untouchable combination of fantastic writing and exceptional artwork rolling onward with another can’t miss issue. The saga behind a royal family member’s death and the impact it has on the officer trying to solve the case continues to be a must have on New Comic Book Day. Thompson, McClarean and Carey have created something truly sensational here and there’s no reason you shouldn’t have this book in your collection.

Hit me up on ODPH social media and let me know what you thought of Black Cloak #4. Thanks for reading!

BLACK CLOAK #4 (IMAGE COMICS)

ODPH Podcast