Welcome to an all new edition of Parlay points, the comic book review blog for the ODPH Podcast!
For this entry, we have arrived at the conclusion of an explosive crossover from DC Comics. Anything Gothan City is the battlefield, readers know Batman will fight anyone to the end to defend it and his vision of justice. However for this fight, it’s his “Bat Family” providing the opposition. Lading the charge is his lover/enemy Selina Kyle aka Catwoman.
The battle has morphed out of a simple question of ethics into a no-holds-barred fight leaving nothing but shattered ties and a city prime to be conquered in its wake.
BATMAN/CATWOMAN: THE GOTHAM WAR - SCORCHED EARTH #1 by Chip Zdarsky, Tini Howard, Mike Hawthorne, Wade Von Grawbadger, Mark Morales, Romulo Fajardo Jr. and Clayton Cowles brings the curtain down on the war for Gotham City’s soul. Let’s see who’s left standing in the end, shall we?
BATMAN/CATWOMAN: THE GOTHAM WAR - SCORCHED EARTH #1 by Chip Zdarsky, Tini Howard, Mike Hawthorne, Wade Von Grawbadger, Mark Morales, Nikola Cizmesija, Arif Prianto and Clayton Cowles - credit: DC Comics - cover: Jorge Jiménez
*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***
Due to the fallout from “Knight Terrors”, Bruce Wayne aka Batman was asleep for quite some time. When he finally wakes up, Gotham City’s crime rate has drastically been reduced. A new initiative has been started amongst the criminals of Gotham. The mastermind behind it? None other than Selina Kyle aka Catwoman!
Selina has been teaching the lower level of criminals a “Robin Hood” style of activity. The movement has lowered crimes in Gotham to astronomical records. This doesn’t sit well with Batman, as he sees all crime as universally bad. It also doesn’t help that Zur-En-Arrh, his emergency back-up personality is active due to the Knight Terrors ramifications. The cold-hearted mindset decrees that Selina’s operation must be stopped after a life is lost during a heist.
Sides have been taken amongst the Bat family. Drastic actions have been taken by Batman with no remorse. Of all the victims, no one was hurt more deeper than Jason Todd aka The Red Hood with the actions of the possessed Dark Knight. All the while during the Bat family civil war, Vandal Savage, the immortal nemesis of the DCU, has swooped in making a play to conquer Gotham. Now with the battle at the breaking point, who walks away the winner of Gotham City?
This issue begins with Scandal Savage, daughter of Vandal and formerly aligned with Catwoman, organizing Selina’s former pupils. They have been given their orders to get the meteor fragments which will give Vandal strength of unknown levels. Meanwhile, Tim Drake (Robin) is heading to investigate an explosion. When he arrives, he and readers aren’t ready for what’s next.
Led by Two-Face, a group of Batman’s rogues make their way down the street, nearly killing a few civilians. Overwhelmed, Tim is taken hostage.
All the while, Batman, Catwoman and Jason are meeting where it appears the real Bruce has come back to the fold. Readers witness a tremendous speech and plea to the family to come together to stop Vandal’s attack. The question now is: Can the broken family refrom and save Gotham?
The answer is aimed to please, but with overwhelming odds, t might not be enough. The ending gives this story fitting epic moments with one especially outshining them all. Its’ fall-out looks to set up a new stat quo but one can’t help but wonder if the bonds have been broken beyond repair?
BATMAN/CATWOMAN: THE GOTHAM WAR - SCORCHED EARTH #1 by Chip Zdarsky, Tini Howard, Mike Hawthorne, Wade Von Grawbadger, Mark Morales, Nikola Cizmesija, Arif Prianto and Clayton Cowles - credit: DC Comics - cover: Salvador Larroca
The writing team bring a great deal of noteworthy events to the finale. Seeing the “old” Batman re-emerge to inspire the family was a solid way to shift gears towards the common enemy of the Savages. At the end of it all, Justice is what both warring sides of the Bat-family want, with Selina being the voice of reason. There are excellent moments with the various family members teaming up but none bigger than “The Cat and The Bat”.
Throughout their history, there’s few like the pairing of Bruce and Selina. Seeing them pair up in the later issues gives readers a reminder of why this conflict has been so personal. The writers carry this mood into the final battle. There’s a fair mix of action and drama that is sure to please.
The epilogue is one that might throw some off. It feels like a reset until something re-surfaces which leaves some questions heading into the future of Bruce Wayne. Overall, it has the “big fight feel” that you ant to see in a finale. How long it lasts will be the thought moving forward.
The art captures the intensity of the ending at hand. the introduction of two-Face and the rogues makes a big splash at how far Gotham has crumbled due to the war. It’s followed up by some great action panels with more of the family involved. The meeting between Bruce, Selina and Jason carries a bug emotional burden of Bruce’s actions.
This reflects later in the issue when Bruce and Selina pair up. There is subtle facial expressions indicating the extreme highs and lows reflecting the conflict and its surrounding factors. Readers will have a lasting impression of what transpired and an idea of where things lead now.
BATMAN/CATWOMAN: THE GOTHAM WAR - SCORCHED EARTH #1 by Chip Zdarsky, Tini Howard, Mike Hawthorne, Wade Von Grawbadger, Mark Morales, Nikola Cizmesija, Arif Prianto and Clayton Cowles - credit: DC Comics - cover: Simone Bianchi
FINAL GRADE: 8 OUT OF 10
When the smoke clears, the fate of Gotham City is made evident to readers with a fitting conclusion to the Bat family civil war. With themes reminding readers about the bond of family through the writing and art, This crossover conclusion is sure to have fans talking on New Comic Book Day.
Hit me up on ODPH social media and let me know your thoughts on BATMAN/CATWOMAN: THE GOTHAM WAR - SCORCHED EARTH #1. Thanks for reading!
