Welcome to an all new edition of Parlay Points, the comic book review blog for the ODPH Podcast!

For this entry, we’re checking out a brand new series from Image Comics that has generated a huge buzz before hitting the LCS. BLACK CLOAK #1 by Kelly Thompson (Eisner Award winner 2021 - Black Widow), Meredith McClaren (Hinges) and Beccy Carey takes readers on a creative whodunit epic blending in many themes along the way. . Considering the creative team behind this book, the hype is well warranted. Let’s take a closer look at what’s happening in this over-sized (50+ pages) debut issue, shall we?

BLACK CLOAK #1 - On sale January 11th, 2023
Creative: Kelly Thompson, Meredith McClaren, and Becca Carey
Credit: Image Comics

*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***

This story kicks off in the city of Kiros. Kiros is described as “the last city in the known world.” Readers discover that many years ago, there was peace made after a devastating war. Now in a state of tranquility, it would appear that things in Kiros should be great. However, it does not seem to be the case. Readers get ushered into a big example of how there’s still danger lurking within the city limits with many different characters living together in this fantastic new world.

A sea-like figure known as a “Maid” (note the fishtales) emerges from the Lagoon, an area within Kiros. The maid appears to die on shore in front of a group of fellow maids. Right behind them, a Elf-human named Dace also emerges lifeless and crashes near the deceased maid, with the group dispersing.

The story now shifts to Merchant Row where readers get introduced to Detective Phaedra Essex, known for wearing a Black Cloak to be identified as law enforcement.Essex handles a routine issue with one of the inhabitants of Kiros, a goat/human-esque figure before getting called away to what will be a shocking crime scene that she won’t be ready for.

That scene is located above the Salty Crow in an apartment in the Narrows. A fellow Black Cloak named Pax is investigating a dead body with royal ink on their arm. The body turns out to be Freyal III of Sidra, the heir apparent to the throne!

From here, Essex reveals a bombshell to Pax involving the deceased! The pair now starts to investigate Freyal’s death. First stop is to the Salty Crow, where more clues are revealed about Freyal. Once back at the station, the pair are called to the lagoon and now investigate the bodies found earlier in the issue.

How/Are they connected to Freyal? With more clues and a rising body count, readers won’t be ready for the next steps in the investigation. The tension keeps building and hits a certain peak when Essex gets clearence to meet with the royalty of Kiros with Freyal’s passing. Those scenes are impactful but get ready for the fallout. No one is going to be ready for that and the final image to close this chapter out.

Talk about a debut issue! With all the complexity of introducing readers to a fantasy world, at its’ core, Black Cloak is an engaging thriller. Thompson establishes that right from the start and never lets that sway what is unfolding here. There are many characters and figures making first impressions but none shine brighter that Detective Phaedra Essex. The character of Essex is a multi-layered figure as her connection to the murder victim drives the story into new directions. In a way, Essex becomes an enigma herself. There is no bigger (or better) example of this than when she meets with the Queen to inform her of Freyal’s death. As that business trip expands, questions become raised about Essex that plant the foundation for bigger answers later in the series. The partnership between Essex and Pax is another strong element in this book. It is very easy to pick up that the pair have been working together for a while and are committed to solving this high profile case with Pax making sure Essex can handle working it with all the emotional baggage involved. For being an over-sized issue, the story moves pretty steady without ever feeling like the leads are dwelling too long on any scene. The writing will lock you in from page one and doesn’t let go till the exclamation point put at the end of the issue!

With as fantastic as the story and writing is, McClaren and Carey match the drama and excitement of this story perfectly. With the fantasy element of Kiros, the characters all have distinctive looks. From the maids in the lagoon to proprietors of the Salty Crow to the Police Station characters and more, Kiros lives up to the “last city in the known world” with all the different residents. The city has many elements to it and for a first issue, it showcased enough to hook people in to find out more. Seeing Essex’s reactions to what unfolds in this issue is also noteworthy. McClaren never keeps the reader guessing on how Phaedra is reacting to a moment. The world of Kiros also is featured to readers as a place where more is going on that anyone realizes. There are many panels that will stand out but none might be greater than the final one page panel to end this issue on. Get ready for that!

FINAL POINT: Black Cloak #1 welcomes readers to a flawless blend of imagination and mystery. Thompson, McClaren and Carey present the world of Kiros with exceptional storytelling and vibrant art. This book will mesmerize readers from the opening page until that huge final page. You won’t want to miss this one at the local comic shops for new comic book day. Highest Possible Recommendation.

Hit me up on ODPH social media and let me know what you thought of Black Cloak #1. Thanks for reading.

BLACK CLOAK #1 (IMAGE COMICS)

Ken M