Welcome to a special edition of Parlay Points, the complementary comic book blog section of the ODPH podcast. For this edition, we’re checking out a brand new comic series heading to the small screen on July 29th. Paper Girls is the latest addition to what is slowly becoming the go-to landing spot for independent comics on TV/streaming via Prime Video. The 2015 Image Comic, created by Brian K. Vaughan (known for Saga, Runaways and Y: the Last Man to name a few) & Cliff Chiang , is a former Eisner winner and now joins the ranks of The Boys and Invincible as the latest independent comics to cross over to Amazon Studios along with Legendary Television, in connection with Plan B.

“Paper Girls” ran until July 2019. Shortly there after, a TV production deal was announced. The show was met with a very positive 2022 San Diego Comic Con panel and is set to premiere (all 8 episodes) with a ton of hype behind it. The ODPHpod was granted early screening privileges to the series so here is out SPOILER FREE review!

The plot synopsis (quote courtesy of Amazon studios) reads as follows: “In the early morning hours after Halloween 1988, four paper girls—Erin, Mac, Tiffany, and KJ—are out on their delivery route when they become caught in the crossfire between warring time-travelers, changing the course of their lives forever. Transported into the future, these girls must figure out a way to get back home to the past, a journey that will bring them face-to-face with the grown-up versions of themselves. While reconciling that their futures are far different than their 12-year-old selves imagined, they are being hunted by a militant faction of time-travelers known as the Old Watch, who have outlawed time travel so that they can stay in power. In order to survive, the girls will need to overcome their differences and learn to trust each other, and themselves.”

The show stars Camryn Jones (playing Tiffany Quilkin), Sofia Rosinsky (Mac Coyle), Riley Lai Nelet (Erin Tieng) and Fina Strazza (KJ Brandman) as the four paper girls in the center of this story. The rest of the cast is filled out by Nate Corddry, Ali Wong and Adina Porter.

Being that this a SPOILER-FREE review, trust me when I say: The show lives up to the early buzz behind it. Whenever time travel is used as a major plot point in a series, it can always be tricky to pull off. Where “Paper Girls” does things right with the series is that it doesn’t focus viewers on the issue at hand. Where this show finds its strength is in the four young actresses who make the show about their journeys finding themselves more than the travel in time. The show allows all four to have their own individual moments without feeling like one overshadows the other.

However, the two actresses that will make strong cases for breakout stars from this season will be Fina Strazza (KJ) and Sofia Rosinsky (Mac). Due to the nature of each of their character’s journeys, both have very impactful performances once the show starts heading into the middle act. This especially holds true for Rosinsky as she shows many different sides to her character. For being only 16 years old, this was a very noteworthy performance from first episode to last. In comparison, Nelet (Erin) and Jones (Tiffany)’s respective arcs tie more into the overall story.

The rest of the cast does a great job bringing the sci-fi aspect to life in this series. There are excellent performances from Porter, Corddry, and Wong who bring the uniqueness of a time traveled world to the viewers. The overall story is one that will have non-readers of the comics engaged but (imo) never feeling lost in where the show is moving. The handling of time travel moments never feels too much and are spaced out well to showcase the leads.

The show does an excellent job with capturing the time periods that they are in as well. For being in 1988 to start, everything from the images surrounding to the music gives the story solid footing. The only “drawback” that might be wrongly mentioned is viewer’s claims that this is too much like Netflix’s “Stranger Things”. In a time period where most of pop culture had its attention drawn into, everything remotely close is being compared to the smash streaming hit. While I can see the comparisons’ idea: (4 young kids fighting something in the 1980’s, weird colorful imagery in the skies), that’s where the arguments end.

“Paper Girls” stands more on the strengths of the leads finding themselves more than fighting monsters in the Upside Down. Once the story gets moving, the direction the story heads is one that is more character driven than most viewers might realize. Sure, there are very noticeable sci-fi elements throughout the show. Do they take anything away form the show. Absolutely not. If anything, they serve as a break from the internal discovery of the leads. At some points, it may not seem to mesh as well, but once you near the conclusion of this run, it pays off. There are a few moments that viewers will be very amped to talk about in that aspect.

Overall, “Paper Girls” presents a strong character driven view into an ever changing landscape of time travel. Viewers will be immersed with the character portrayals of such a young cast. Each display their stories with many moving parts. It’s equally balanced out by a supporting cast that makes the fiction element feel somewhat normal without making the viewers disenfranchised to the overall theme.

As David Bowie once said: “Time may change me … But I can't trace time”

Don’t miss “Paper Girls” debuting all 8 episodes on Prime Video on July 29th

Hit me up on Twitter and let me know what you thought of the series. Thanks for reading!

PAPER GIRLS (PRIME VIDEO - AMAZON STUDIOS)

Ken M